Grandpa (Lawrence) Montgomery was a great storyteller. So great that sometimes it’s hard to determine how much of his stories were rooted in fact and how much was fabrication or, perhaps, misremembering. One of Grandpa’s best stories I mentioned here briefly back in 2014, but I thought I’d take a closer look at it and the facts that might lie behind it.
The story has its roots in provable fact. Grandpa did, indeed, lie about his age and join the Army when he was 15, claiming a birth year of 1898 when he was actually born in 1901. His Army discharge papers show the erroneous age as well as confirm his military service. He first enlisted 6 April 1917 at Fort Logan, Colorado. He was honorably discharged at Camp Dodge, Iowa, two years later. The very next day he re-enlisted. His second enlistment lasted a single year, and he was again honorably discharged, this time on 18 April 1920 at Fort McIntosh, Texas. He was listed as entitled to travel pay to Fort Collins, Colorado, where his father still lived.
Grandpa had many stories about those three intervening years. He told of being stationed in Hawaii and of seeing someone walk by carrying a huge bunch of bananas still on the stem. When the banana man asked if Grandpa wanted to buy “a banana,” Grandpa said yes, and then the man handed over the entire stalk and walked away.
He also told of the soldiers burning an effigy of Kaiser Wilhelm (this was during World War I), and Grandpa being made to shimmy up the pole to cut the effigy down.
But I always thought Grandpa’s best story was the one he told of working in the movie theater on base. At that time movies were made of cellulose nitrate film and were extremely flammable, so there were strict rules forbidding smoking in the projection rooms. One one occasion (relayed Grandpa), he was at his projection duties when a couple of men came in, one with a lit cigar in his mouth. Grandpa immediately yelled at the man to put out his cigar, and the men left. Only afterward did one of Grandpa’s fellow soldiers ask him, “You do know that was General Pershing, don’t you?”
I mean, what a great story, right? And probably not one that can ever be proven or disproven. But we can certainly investigate the available facts and learn more about Grandpa’s life in the process. I still remember, years after first hearing the Pershing story, when I actually saw Grandpa’s discharge papers, one fact stood out:

There it is in black and white (or maybe white and gray?), listed under his military experiences: “Knowledge of any vocation: Moving picture Operator.” So there is at least a kernel of truth in that Grandpa would definitely have been in the projection room on base. Whether Pershing was also there at the same time is uncertain; perhaps I need to read a biography of Pershing rather than just perusing his Wikipedia article. Pershing was certainly in Texas while chasing after Pancho Villa, but this would have been before Grandpa’s time there. Maybe the incident happened to one of Grandpa’s predecessors in the projection room and Grandpa commandeered the tale?
Grandpa’s Hawaii tales (well, not specifically the banana thing) also prove to have basis in fact. His first set of discharge papers notes that he served in Company K, 2nd Infantry. The Wikipedia article for the 2nd Infantry Regiment notes that this unit never saw duty during World War I because they were on security duty in Hawaii before returning to the United States and being assigned to the 19th Division at Camp Dodge. The war ended just before those in this regiment could be sent overseas.1
What else, you may ask, did the 2nd Infantry do in Hawaii? On 18 November 1917, they were one of many groups who made up the huge procession that was part of the state funeral of Queen Liliʻuokalani, who had died on 11 November.2 Colonel Bolles, commander of the 2nd Infantry, appeared in one of numerous photographs of the funeral in the 19 November Honolulu Star-Bulletin. I’m still looking closely to see if I can see a 16-year-old Grandpa marching somewhere behind.


























Instrument No. 407443 Honorable Discharge from The United States Army