It’s not every day that you discover your relative had a connection to a TV portrayal by a soon-to-be Mouseketeer. My third cousin four times removed, Edward Sweeney Bentley, was born 16 January 1860 in Knights Ferry, California. As you might guess, he was one of our Sweeney relatives. His father had been born in Kentucky but moved to California in 1850, where he mined for several years.1
In 1860 the Bentley family, consisting of J[efferson] D., age 33; wife Elizabeth, age 27; and son Edward, age 5/12; were enumerated in Buena Vista, California.2 Ten years later in Empire, Stanislaus County, Mary M., 7; Sarah A., 4; and Jefferson, 1/12, had been added to the family.3 By 1880 the family (still in Empire) now included Maria E., 7; James, 4; Jefferson’s mother, Jane, 77; and Elizabeth’s brother, John Bishop, 36.4 Cousin Edward wouldn’t live to the next census enumeration. His glowing obituary in The Modesto [California] Bee indicated he had worked as a blacksmith in Turlock and then in Placer, then moved to Kern County around 1887, where he worked in real estate as well as acting as a Deputy Constable.5

On 22 February 1889 Edward had been to Visalia to purchase land and was returning by train when the train stopped unexpectedly. When Edward and the train brakeman went to investigate, Edward was shot without warning. Another passenger, Charles Gobart, had walked down the other side of the train to investigate as well; he was also shot and died instantly. Unbeknownst to Edward and Charles, two masked men had boarded the train at Pixley, California intent on robbery. The robbers stole $420 from the train’s safe and fled. Edward, still alive, was taken to the town of Delano, and his parents were summoned by telegram, but after about a week he succumbed to his injuries. He was buried 1 March 1889 in Modesto’s Acacia Memorial Park.6

An article in the San Francisco Chronicle dated 24 February 1889 gave further details of the crime, though there were conflicting accounts from the various eyewitnesses. Were there five masked men? Four? Three? Two? Detectives and others were sent in pursuit of the robbers, however many there were, and the Governor of California later offered a reward of $250 for their capture.7 8
It would be some time before the criminals were identified. Following the Pixley robbery, numerous others were committed with more men killed. The robbers fled yet again. It wasn’t until 5 August 1892 (coincidentally, the day after the Lizzie Borden murders) that a drunk man wandered through the fifteen saloons in Visalia, California, telling everyone he met how he had been on the train during one of the recent robberies. A bartender alerted detective Will Smith, who notified Deputy George Witty, who picked up the the intoxicated man, George Sontag, and interrogated him. The interview convinced the undersheriff and detectives doing the questioning that George had not been on the train in question (which turned out to be true) but that he knew too much to be completely disconnected from the crime (which also turned out to be true).
Smith and Witty went back to the house where George and his brother John had met up at the home of the family of Chris Evans. They saw John Sontag enter the home and asked Eva Evans (Chris’s daughter and John’s fiancée) where John had gone. When Chris came out to see what was happening, he told the officers John had gone downtown, which the officers knew to be untrue. Smith entered the house, and John came out carrying a shotgun. Shooting ensued. Sontag and Evans fled yet again, but now they had been identified.
Chris Evans had met John Sontag around 1887; Chris relayed to John the story of the accident in which an iron rail pierced his lung while he was working for the Southern Pacific Railroad, and how the railroad did not try to make amends to him for the disability he had suffered. Chris Evans invited John Sontag to return to his home with him. They worked together after that – sometimes hauling lumber, sometimes running a livery stable, and sometimes robbing trains.
Finally in June 1893, after nearly a year of hiding, Evans and Sontag, planning to return to Visalia, saw the posse that was searching for them near a cabin at Stone Corral Canyon. They planned to abscond with the posse’s horses, but they were seen. In the shootout that ensued, Chris was shot in the eye and arm but eventually fled (again), while John Sontag, even more seriously wounded, was taken captive. Chris Evans was soon captured as well, at the home of some friends who alerted the authorities. John Sontag would die of his wounds on 3 July 1893. In December 1893 Chris Evans was convicted and sentenced to life in prison. In spite of a prison break somewhere in between there, Chris’s “life sentence” amounted to less than 18 years; he was released 1 May 1911 and died in 1917.
Some 60 years after the Stone Corral Canyon shootout, it was immortalized in a 1955 episode of the TV series Stories of the Century. In this episode, a “Deputy Ed” is portrayed by Jimmie Dodd, who would begin starring later that year in The Mickey Mouse Club.9 This “Deputy Ed,” in spite of his name and occupation, is apparently not our cousin Edward Sweeney Bentley, who was already dead before the events of the episode took place. But you, too, can watch this episode on the Tubi streaming platform. You know you want to.
- J. Harvey Sweeney, Jr., Moses Sweeney Descendants (n.p: 2006, n.d). ↩︎
- The National Archives in Washington D.C.; Record Group: Records of the Bureau of the Census; Record Group Number: 29; Series Number: M653; Residence Date: 1860; Home in 1860: Buena Vista, Stanislaus, California; Roll: M653_70; Page: 722; Family History Library Film: 803070 ↩︎
- Year: 1870; Census Place: Empire, Stanislaus, California; Roll: M593_92; Page: 39B ↩︎
- Year: 1880; Census Place: Empire, Stanislaus, California; Roll: 84; Page: 359d; Enumeration District: 095 ↩︎
- The Modesto [California] Bee, Modesto, California, 5 March 1889, pg. 3 ↩︎
- Find a Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/22511762/edward_s-bentley: accessed August 30, 2025), memorial page for Edward S Bentley (16 Jan 1860–28 Feb 1889), Find a Grave Memorial ID 22511762, citing Acacia Memorial Park, Modesto, Stanislaus County, California, USA; Maintained by Barbara O (contributor 47314130). ↩︎
- San Francisco Chronicle, 24 February 1889, pg. 15 ↩︎
- The San Francisco Call Bulletin, 9 March 1889, pg. 8 ↩︎
- Internet Movie Database, Jimmie Dodd article, https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0230082/?ref_=mv_close ↩︎

















